Second Cape Henry Lighthouse, Fort Story
| Rebecca Cooke Herbert | 1951-1953 | |
| Allie Tynes | 1953-1956 | |
| Anita Malbon | 1956-1959 | |
| Lillian Patterson Robertson | 1959-1962 | |
| Mellie Rose Moore | 1962-1965 | |
| J. Fletcher Bryant | 1965-1968 | |
| Mrs. Barnard White | 1968-1971 | |
| Marilyn Spain | 1971-1974 | |
| Kaye Frances Walker Mitchell | 1974-1977 | |
| Margaret Bonner Smith | 1977-1980 | |
| Mary Anne Nixon | 1980-1983 | |
| Martha Carr Huddleston | 1983-1986 | |
| Melinda Graham Kicklighter | 1986-1989 | |
| Edwina Deutermann Walsh | 1989-1995 | |
| M. Annette Taylor | 1995-1998 | |
| Martha Butler Brosch | 1998-2001 | |
| Susan Chamberlin Hall | 2001-2004 | |
| Sue Anne Volkening Fibish | 2004-2007 | |
| Jennie Lou Pangle | 2007-2013 | |